Asian Invasion
Baseball’s Ambassadors
by Alexander Blenkinsopp
From International Law, Vol. 24 (1) - Spring 2002
Print     Email article 1 2 Next

ALEXANDER BLENKINSOPP is a Senior Editor at the Harvard International Review.

The 2001 US Major League Baseball (MLB) season heralded greater prominence for a relatively new presence in the American national pastime—that of Asian baseball players.

Ichiro Suzuki—better known as “Ichiro”— after dominating Japanese pitchers for seven years, joined the Seattle Mariners as the first Asian-born position player to sign a major-league contract. He became the American League (AL) batting champion and top vote-getter in the All-Star Game, earned both a Silver Slugger Award and a Gold Glove Award, and was elected both AL Rookie of the Year and AL Most Valuable Player (MVP).

Ichiro’s achievements, which made him a household name in the United States, were not last season’s sole accomplishments by Asian defectors to the major leagues. Hideo Nomo, a previous recipient of Japan’s equivalent of the Cy Young Award for pitching success in a season, threw his second career no-hitter for the Boston Red Sox this past April. South Korean-born Byung-Hyun Kim led the World Series champion Arizona Diamondbacks in saves, playing an integral role in their yearlong success before faltering in two World Series games. Japanese Kazuhiro Sasaki served as the Mariners’ closer in the most successful season of the franchise’s history. Other Asian exports have become significant players in North America, including Japanese Shigetoshi Hasegawa, Tsuyoshi Shinjo, Masato Yoshii, and Hideki Irabu, as well as South Koreans Chan-Ho Park and Sun-Woo Kim.

This influx of talent from Asian nations, though likely to accelerate with time, does not promise to resemble the spate of Latin American ballplayers which has changed the face of American baseball over the past 30 years. Acceleration will result from the greater attention paid to professional Asian baseball leagues, especially with the appreciable success of past imports. The Japanese and Korean baseball leagues, however, can be expected to limit the mining of their leagues by the United States, creating roadblocks to MLB’s signing of players from Asia.

Some fans and commentators have likened the emergence of Asia as a source of baseball talent to the attention afforded to Latin America by major league ballclubs. The analogy is surprisingly apt. In 1996, the New York Mets and San Diego Padres opened the season in Monterrey, Mexico, in the first regular-season game played outside the United States and Canada. Four years later, the Mets took on the Chicago Cubs at the Tokyo Dome to inaugurate the 2000 season in the first regular-season game played in Asia. The season openers demonstrated a growing awareness of the increasingly prominent contributions made by Latin America and Asia to the MLB.

During the 1960s and early 1970s, Puerto Rican Roberto Clemente changed the landscape of American baseball as a member of the Pittsburgh Pirates, which ultimately earned him a plaque in baseball’s Hall of Fame. Similarly, Dominican Sammy Sosa has in recent years changed the sport as few other ballplayers have, with his prodigious home runs for the Chicago Cubs. His consistent superstar numbers have launched him both into the record books and to the status of fan favorite. However, Clemente and Sosa stand taller than their mere statistics and accolades. They have come to represent a culture’s presence in baseball, and they have increased the awareness of the talent that Latin America offers to baseball.

Ichiro, like Clemente or Sosa in the past, changed the baseball world last year with one of the best all-around seasons in history. In the same way as Clemente and Sosa, he has come to represent a foreign culture’s presence in baseball, increasing the awareness of potential Asian talent.

This increased awareness is far from negligible. Scouts for major league teams have facilitated the expected importation of about 15 more players from Asia even before the start of the 2002 season. The Los Angeles Dodgers and the Chicago Cubs, among others, have Asians in their minor league systems primed to break into the big leagues within the next few years. Numerous franchises have significantly expanded their scouting programs in the continent in hopes of seeing the next Ichiro into their team’s uniform.

Despite the strong efforts made by teams to attract Asian talent to the big leagues, though, a number of factors will prevent Asia from turning into another Latin America. An important one is that the professional leagues in Japan and Korea—the continent’s two prime sources of baseball talent—maintain a tight grip on their players. In 1964, pitcher Masanori Murakami became the first Asian player to come to the United States and play in the major leagues. After little more than one season of solid relief appearances as a member of the San Francisco Giants, however, Murakami returned to Japan. His departure was prompted by a contractual imbroglio between the San Francisco Giants and the Nankai Hawks that almost led US baseball commissioner Ford Frick to demand a break in all relations between US teams and Japanese leagues.

Nearly four decades later, Asian baseball leagues have only slightly loosened their grips on their players. While no restrictions prohibit players from Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, Mexico, or most other Latin American nations from playing for US major league teams (Cuba is a notable exception), Asian players face several limitations. In Japan, players are bound to their clubs for a full nine years—most often encompassing the prime of their careers—before they can seek employment with US or Canadian teams. Korean players must complete two years of military service before they turn 27 years old, binding them to their countries until they complete their stints in the armed forces and depriving them of two seasons of experience. Park, South Korea’s most successful export to the United States, was exempted from his mandatory military service after leading South Korea to a gold medal in baseball at the 1998 Asian Games. Asian players must also cut through many layers of legal and residential red tape (e.g. problems with visas) before even arriving in the United States to play.

Many Asian players enjoy financial security at home without the added burdens of cultural and linguistic barriers or distance from their families. Furthermore, Asian players may face lower job security in the United States due to a higher concentration of talent and skill in the major leagues. An additional obstacle is a contrast in the style of baseball played in Asia and the United States. American baseball emphasizes home runs, while Asian baseball has traditionally stressed contact hitting without the need for great power. Ichiro himself exemplifies this; he hit only eight home runs, the fewest by an AL position player MVP since 1959.

1 2 Next